Brought to you by:
Powered by wagescape.com
Labor Market Pulse
Youngstown-Warren-Boardman, OH-PA Metro Edition
Focus: FINANCE
Youngstown finance talent tightens as labor force shrinks, not unemployment.
5.0%
Mahoning County unemployment
Up from 4.6% in July, down from 5.1% year ago
-1,400
Ohio financial activities employment
August monthly decline, ODJFS data
$26.03
Metro avg hourly wage
vs $33.54 national average (May 2025 BLS)
-95,000
Ohio labor force change
Year over year, 10th-largest US decline
This Month's Takeaways
Senior Accountant pay is falling locally while demand isn't.
Metro median advertised pay for Senior Accountant dropped significantly to $75,269, well below the $87,731 national median, even as Ohio F&A leaders report finding skilled professionals harder than a year ago. A widening pay gap against national rates may be masking a role at risk of losing candidates to remote or out-of-metro offers rather than reflecting genuine local demand softening.
Credit Analyst and Tax Specialist pay is moving up together.
Both roles show significant upward movement locally — Credit Analyst to $67,188 and Tax Specialist to $54,034 — suggesting employers are competing harder for compliance and risk-adjacent finance talent even as broader headcount growth slows. Budget cycles built on flat compensation assumptions for these roles likely understate true market cost.
FP&A Manager pay strength points to forecasting talent as a premium line.
Metro FP&A Manager pay rose moderately to $125,017, nearly matching the $127,341 national figure — unusual given the metro's persistent wage gap in most other finance roles. Consistent with national data showing AI-skilled forecasting talent commanding real premiums, this narrowing gap suggests FP&A capacity is being priced as a strategic hire, not a backfill.
Ohio's shrinking labor force is a budget-cycle problem, not a headline number.
Ohio's labor force is down 95,000 from a year ago, even as the state unemployment rate fell — meaning fewer people are competing for finance roles, not more. Headcount cost models anchored to easing unemployment may understate retention pressure building beneath the surface.
Local Labor Conditions
Mahoning and Trumbull County unemployment rose to 5.0% and 5.1% respectively in August, up from July, even as both counties remain below year-ago levels — a sign of a labor force still contracting faster than job losses accumulate. Financial activities employment fell statewide by 1,400 in August, compounding a metro where hourly wages already trail the national average by nearly $7.50, tightening the pool of experienced finance talent available to local employers.
Leadership & Talent Implications
Rising county unemployment paired with a shrinking labor force is not the same signal — Youngstown employers face fewer available workers even as headline joblessness ticks up, meaning open finance requisitions may sit longer regardless of unemployment optics. Statewide financial activities contraction, combined with Ohio's F&A hiring managers reporting sharply higher difficulty filling skilled roles, suggests close-cycle and audit-support staffing plans built on prior-year fill rates need revisiting. Consider reviewing headcount contingency plans for controller and senior accountant functions against a longer time-to-fill assumption than 2025 budgets anticipated.
